BETTER LATE THAN NEVER
Looks like Black Robe Mafia went with the original plan. As of today Margaret Downie is listed as Presiding Disciplinary Judge.
Now all State Bar of Arizona has to do is show us that Downie oath!!! Or we can just check to see if it was filed properly per the Arizona constitution.
After that we can play a little game called...
Did former chief counsel for State Bar of Arizona, Margaret Downie take her oath of office as Presiding Disciplinary Judge on May 17th, 2021 as advertised by the Arizona Supreme Court? The official government website still shows William J. O'Neil as the current PDJ.
Prior to announcing the supposed May 17th take over by Downie, she was the Executive Director for Arizona Commission on Judicial Cond
Clip Artist Films discovered this week that the Arizona Supreme Court was advertising on LinkedIn for a new Presiding Disciplinary Judge. When clicking on the link it claims the job is no longer available.
Was this an old ad before Downie was announced in March of this year?
If it was an old advertisement, then it would prove to be an attempt to defraud the public as it's self evident that Downie w
This week regional and national news stories started disappearing.
PHOENIX, ARIZONA - APRIL 2021 - Salary and pension of Arizona Supreme Court Disciplinary Judge William J. O’Neil at jeopardy of being stopped? Clip Artist Films obtained a legally served document copy by process server against the Arizona State Personnel Board, dated April 5, 2021. The document entitled as a “Demand Letter”, requested to stop all salary and pension paid to O’Neil. Star Moffatt and investigative journalist with Moffatt Media researched, compiled and carefully preserved the documents proving O’Neil is in actuality an unconstitutionally seated judge due to lack of a valid Oath of Office, which proves fraudulent. Importantly, the letter legally served upon the Arizona Personnel Board asks for a referral of O’Neil to law enforcement for criminal prosecution alleging he’s impersonating a judicial official.
Moffatt was able to produce a 2017 forensic analysis submitted by Marcel B. Matley, Document and Handwriting Expert, that proves O’Neil’s Oath of Office is a fake-fraudulent document according to A.R.S. 38-231. Matley’s willing to testify in a court of law, stating he would “prepare appropriate court exhibits by which to illustrate and explain my observations, opinions and reasons.”
In 1988 Matley authored, “Forgery, detection and defense: A guidebook for the legal professional”, further giving special weight to his analysis and opinion. The nationally respected expert has been in practice since 1985 and certified by the National Association of Document Examiners since 2000. In the explosive forensic analysis, Matley concludes the Oath of Office is unsigned and an artifice when compared to standardized documents which are contemporaneous to O’Neil’s alleged oath and others obtained through the Arizona Secretary of State.
On January 3rd, 2011, Judge Robert M. Brutinel signed “Loyalty Oath of Office” referencing A.R.S. 38-231 in the document. The statute clearly states. “Any officer or employee who fails to take and subscribe to the oath or affirmation provided by this section within the time limits prescribed by this section is not entitled to any compensation until the officer or employee does so take and subscribe to the form of oath or affirmation prescribed by this section.” The appointment for Arizona Supreme Court Judge Brutinel became official on January 10th, 2011. Other documents obtained indicate the Oath of Office of Presiding Disciplinary Judge William J. O’Neil being administered just one day later on January 11th, 2011 by Honorable Rebecca White Berch.
In further descriptive observations Matley goes on to say, “Exhibit A has no handwritten material nor is there any data as to either the occasion or cause for the Oath of Office except the second to last subordinate clause states “the Office of Presiding Judge.” No other person but Honorable O’ Neil and Honorable Rebecca White Berch, solely as administering the oath, are mentioned. Exhibit A has the stylistic characteristics of neither form nor a format for a standardized document. This type is all letters in sans serif of a uniform size. The text is of single sentence broken into seven subordinate clauses which are centered down the page. The document is undated as well as unsigned either Honorable O’ Neil or Honorable Berch.”
O’Neil’s Oath of Office analyzed by Matley in 2017 was obtained directly from the “Office of the Presiding Disciplinary Judge” itself in an official email from email@example.com dated February 4th, 2016. All other documents supporting this press release have been gathered over a period of 5 years by a team of investigative journalists concerned with making sure the public is aware of the overt fraudulent activities by the Arizona Supreme Court and O’Neil.
Transferring power in 2010, the Supreme Court of Arizona appointed O’ Neil to be Arizona’s first Presiding Disciplinary Judge. Clip Artist Films has been unable to find a new law or statute since Arizona Supreme Court transferred the unilateral power of attorney discipline to the new office, which would override or supersede O’Neil’s requirements to comply with A.R.S. 38-231. Since taking office the rogue judge has used one of the most powerful judicial posts in Arizona as a weapon to unfairly rule against Arizona Attorneys.
In a news release by Arizona Supreme Court on February 11th, 2021, the new Chief Justice commented, “In 2010, the Arizona Supreme Court selected Judge O’Neil to serve as the state’s first Presiding Disciplinary Judge as part of an innovative approach to managing attorney regulation and discipline cases for the court. Judge O’Neil’s experience as a trial judge and Pinal County presiding judge was critical to successfully establishing the office of Presiding Disciplinary Judge. Judge O’Neil set a standard for efficiency and fairness that creates a benchmark for the Presiding Disciplinary Judges to come. The court is grateful to Judge O’Neil for his service and his commitment to court improvement and wishes him the best in retirement.”
On February 12th, 2021, local Phoenix Fox affiliate reported that O’Neil informed Chief Justice Brutinel he would be retiring as soon as the Arizona Supreme Court found a replacement for him. With the 2019 resignation of Justice Bales, Brutinel took over the top spot of Chief Justice.”
Unfortunately for the citizens of Arizona, the comments by Brutneli are an obvious attempt to suspend reality. In a fitting example of synchronicity, Brutinel’s very own 2011 Oath of Office proves the O’Neil’s is an artifice, then 10 years later now Chief Justice Brutneli white washes the record. O’Neil’s rulings were anything other than efficient and fair. Based on our investigative journalism, it’s the opinion of Clip Artist Films the office of Presiding Disciplinary Judge itself was created by the Supreme Court of Arizona as an illegal transfer of power to unconstitutionally seat Judge O’Neil, making all of O’Neil’s rulings, decisions and orders since 2011, “Null and Void!”
On May 17th, 2021 Margaret Downie is scheduled to take over the Office of Presiding Disciplinary Judge. Will the Oath of Office match O'Neil's or the legitimate standard? Will the document be filed with the Arizona Secretary of State?
In Downie's recent position of being the Executive Director in charge of judge discipline, makes her the perfect choice FOR THEM. Margaret has suspended or removed 0.0 judges since taking that spot over in 2017. Before PROTECTING every judge in Arizona from judicial misconduct cases, from 1988-1997 Margaret Downie served in the “discipline department” at State Bar of Arizona, a fact conveniently left off of all MSM articles found online about her new appointment. Back then Margaret earned her brownie points by proving loyalty to the black robe mafia, Downie became chief bar counsel for the corrupt non-profit.
The obvious effort to be a gatekeeper to protect judges, rather than to her job is self evident in the lack of ANY suspensions or removals issued since 2017. This in spite of Arizona was documented the most corrupt state in the country by Harvard study in 2014, just a few years before she took the post.
#TheUnevenPodcast - Looking for interviews of citizens that have had Jennifer C Ryan-Touhill in a family law or criminal case.
To offer fair and balanced reporting, also looking for any litigant that's had Jennifer Ryan-Touhill in either a criminal or family law case as their judge who had a positive experience. Actually very interested in any positive ones so we can compare those cases and determine how and why the alleged bias by Touhill is procured. According to these many reviews, it seems probable that her record needs to be looked at for the good of the public. Best way to do that is by interviewing citizens who have had a case with her, good or bad. The body to either suspend or revoke a judge is completely broken. There has to be a felony committed for them to get off legally on suspending or removing a judge. Problem with that is all kinds of felonies are committed, however the acts are protected under judicial immunity, or if a public corruption crime is committed, it will never see the light of day to be prosecuted due to the #THIINBLACKLINE of the Black Robe Mafia. So as a journalist, I believe it's more important than ever to make bring judicial wrong doing to light for the public to disseminate.
Here's a review from a criminal defense attorney, according to the oversight website, Robing Room.
"I guess the best way to explain this judge is by saying WOW. I am trying to find the words to explain her. She refereed to a young man who was there defending his mother as STUPID. Yes she called him STUPID. The 16 year old was clearly scared and struggling to understand her rapid fire questions with her loud tone. The young man was clearly broken and needed time to think. A little compassion would have made this a better day. I have never seen a judge speak to someone the way she did, I wanted to jump up and scream at her. As I read all the reviews on her there is clearly a problem with this judge."
News@ClipArtistFilms.com Copyright © 2016-2020 ClipArtistFilms.com - All Rights Reserved
DON'T BE QUIET - WHISTLEBLOW